Jump to content
burnthebox

Ballyglunin railway station

Recommended Posts

It is beyond me why Ireland still has so much difficulty taking advantage of this as a tourist attraction, preserving railways, or housing the likes of the Fry Model railway :facepalm:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

I guess it comes down to having the man/woman power to make it happen and also a plan that can work and everyone singing from the same hymn sheet.

 

I have to say that restoring the station back to as it was in the film could be interesting as it is on a route that could be rebuilt at some stage.

 

Building a replica locomotives and carriage's now that would be something else, but it is do able, just ask the Lynton and Barnstaple railway in North Devon as they are doing just that.

 

It would make a fine model (now that's an idea)

Edited by Colin R

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)
It is beyond me why Ireland still has so much difficulty taking advantage of this as a tourist attraction, preserving railways, or housing the likes of the Fry Model railway :facepalm:

 

This might have a good chance of success if it could milk the sentiments of the Irish American community, but much like the Irish themselves it may be all well meaning idle chatter with little opening of purse strings. Basically the "someone should do something" attitude.

If it was GAA or Tidy Towns there would be no shortage of volunteers and people willing to roll up sleeves or throw money in the pot. ..but railways...not so much.

 

As an aside, one of the main locations in the movie, the cottage, is still in a ruined state after years of attempts at restoration and (typically) a legal squabble over ownership, all the while sightseers have been helping themselves to stones and other materials from it.

Edited by minister_for_hardship

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A great reference for the shades of green used in CIE flying snail era

 

[video=youtube;L6YrqZ7HZ-0]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In my 25+ years involved in the financial side of both the RPSI and DCDR, there was a perpetual chorus of "why don't you restore X" and "it's a scandal that Y has been left to rot in a siding at Downwhiteheadpatrick". Worse still, "the DCDRPSITG says they're into preservation, so they have a duty to rescue the last Hunsletcraven".

 

It got to the stage where I could barely contain my thoughts at AGMs, while sitting at the top table fielding questions. The answers - the printable ones anyway - which I might have given would include....

 

Are YOU going to pay for it?

 

Where will the money come from, given that it isn't currently eligible for grant aid?

 

Will YOU spend every weekend, a fair portion of your days off and annual leave, plus you own petrol money, on working on this in all weathers?

 

Don't you think that a hard-pressed, necessarily under-resourced volunteer workforce have enough to do?

 

.....and so on.

 

The reality is, people across this island have very little interest in industrial heritage compared to other places.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Jon

 

HEAR, HEAR!

 

The number of times I've heard people say "wouldn't it be great to get No.800 out of the museum".

 

But ask them for a a few Euros towards it and ……….

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Jon

 

HEAR, HEAR!

 

The number of times I've heard people say "wouldn't it be great to get No.800 out of the museum".

 

But ask them for a a few Euros towards it and ……….

 

 

EGG-ZACTLY!

 

(I'll throw half a million into that 800 project once I've won the lotto. Who'll cough up the rest?)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
EGG-ZACTLY!

 

(I'll throw half a million into that 800 project once I've won the lotto. Who'll cough up the rest?)

 

800 is too heavy, so you'll also have to win the Euro millions lottery to pay for the upgrading of the track work on the Belfast-Dublin route :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
800 is too heavy, so you'll also have to win the Euro millions lottery to pay for the upgrading of the track work on the Belfast-Dublin route :)

 

She weighs less than a 201, although her axle loading is a bit higher. It's the platform edges and bridges you'd have to keep an eye on (not to mention the hammer blow from the cylinders)...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
She weighs less than a 201. It's the platform edges and bridges you'd have to keep an eye on (not to mention the hammer blow from the cylinders)...

 

Ah Right so. :) I thought I read somewhere the axle loading might be too high for main line use, and wheel spin could buckle some modern track. I presume none of the functioning turn tables could accommodate 800 anyway.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
800 is too heavy, so you'll also have to win the Euro millions lottery to pay for the upgrading of the track work on the Belfast-Dublin route :)

 

No probs. I'll take it to the DCDR. Replacing the track there will be cheaper.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think the one thing that the guys at the Ballyglunin Railway Station project are missing is a serious Business plan or at lease a properly costed project. I would over estimate it to the tune of £5 million pounds or 5.6 Million Euros.

 

This figure would include the complete restoration of the station, signal cabin and good shed and both platforms. Plus the building of a replica steam loco* and four carriages as per the film.

 

In the film there is a footbridge, but I have not include the cost of building a replica footbridge, I believe the original one has been moved to another station, so getting that back is possibly not an option at present. I have also not included the cost for the installation of a train shed to keep the loco and train undercover when the place is not open or the purchase of an industrial Diesel loco to move the train from the shed to the platform.

 

While the line in not operational by IR at present. it would be a good idea to also consider the re-installation of the station track plan again should the need arise and the route is rebuild once again.

 

* it would be possible to build a cheaper loco if you did not want to steam it, but only have a dummy. My personal feeling is that if you are going to all this trouble to build a replica, you might as well build one to work.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Building a new operational loco would be ideal, but would cost upwards of €500k, and then a whole business of health & safety & operational tests and standards. Carriages would then be needed.....

 

Certainly do-able, but the station itself would be a better focus.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quite a contrast to tiny volunteer groups in remote parts of the United States like the Galloping Goose Histroical Society in Dolores Colorado who are prepared to fund their own restoration without the expectation of Government funding.

 

http://www.gallopinggoose5.org/what-we-do/

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The reality is, people across this island have very little interest in industrial heritage compared to other places.

 

Or built heritage in general, 100's of towns and villages up and down the country have historic great houses, castles etc. etc. simply crumbling away and falling down.

Clearly everything can't be preserved, but people here are far more interested in other things.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quite a contrast to tiny volunteer groups in remote parts of the United States like the Galloping Goose Histroical Society in Dolores Colorado who are prepared to fund their own restoration without the expectation of Government funding.

 

http://www.gallopinggoose5.org/what-we-do/

 

because they know they'd get no government funding - US govt too busy pumping it into the military

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Building a new operational loco would be ideal, but would cost upwards of €500k, and then a whole business of health & safety & operational tests and standards. Carriages would then be needed.....

 

Certainly do-able, but the station itself would be a better focus.

 

A replica loco etc. would be pie-in-the-sky stuff.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
A replica loco etc. would be pie-in-the-sky stuff.

 

You say that, but the Lynton and Barnstaple Railway are in the process of building five brand new steam locos and there are as well a number of new build main line certificated steam locos being undertaken in the UK today.

 

I understand that you have to be realistic about such projects and somethings like this wouldn't go ahead without so much of the funding being in place to start with.

 

It is no good expecting the average railway enthusiast to stump up the money for such a project, as it will never happen. What is more likely is if those behind the project are willing to look at sponsorship from a number of sources. Ireland being in the EU, would I think still be entitled to apply for cultural and tourist based grants. This process is not that easy or quick, but it is possible.

 

It would also be tying down all the possible reasons why the project should succeed, such as increase in tourism, the creation of jobs for the project and surrounding local businesses, in the UK a base figure of of every one job created by the project, it creates two more in the local tourist community (always a good one with politicians), interpretation of the local culture, sustainability of the project (would rebuilding the railway station to a standard that trains could run for there again benefit the local community?) what long term assistance could IR give to the project?

 

This is not an endless list of things to consider, but as they say, it always helps to think outside of the box (whatever that means).

 

Of course we also have to remember that not all grant applications are successful, but by thinking about all those issues and more, it will give you a better chance of success in the long term.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
You say that, but the Lynton and Barnstaple Railway are in the process of building five brand new steam locos and there are as well a number of new build main line certificated steam locos being undertaken in the UK today.

 

I realise there's a number of new builds up and running or in planning stages in the uk.

I was referring to the situ here.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As one involved with EU and other grant applications over the last thirty years, I might point out a few conditions that are standard now;

 

1. 100% funding or anything near it is almost never considered, especially for large amounts. Thus, substantial financial input from the promoter is necessary. This being the case, in an Irish context it can mean members coughing up till they bleed!

 

2. Before ANY railway preservation scheme is considered, financial sustainability must be proven. For British preserved lines it's a given - one good gala weekend there will bring in the equivalent of the DCDR's entire annual income, Santas included.

 

3. Very often match funding is a requirement - typically of about 30-50%.

 

Thus, typically but not always, if you have a small project of say £200k, here's what might happen.

 

EU provides £120 - provided.....

Applicant provides at least £55k

Some other sponsor e.g. a tourist board or local authority - provides £25k.

 

Local authorities in the 32 counties have had an absolutely abysmal record in funding anything transport related - throughout all time. With funding cuts across the board, and six of those counties cutting themselves out if EU funding, this doesn't look like changing soon!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We at the MRSI attended a fund raising day last year in Ballyglunin

It was a wet and miserable day and the numbers attending were not great but those that did attend were very passionate about the restoration project

To that effect we took a lot of pics and measurements and hope to build a model of this historical station to be presented to the committee when finished

Scale it yet to be decided but it will most likely be a static display in 00 or N

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Wrenneire

 

Did you take any details of the signal cabin and good shed as well? And would there be any chance of sharing you pictures and measurements, You are correct about it making a brilliant model.

 

I have been thinking about this as a 4mm 21mm gauge exhibition layout since I found this forum.

 

Colin

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I will get back to you Colin, there are a couple of people involved and its a matter of collating all the info we have

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


×

Important Information

Terms of Use